Photography in the Age of Electronic Imaging in Photography: a Critical Introduction dicusses the transition from analouge to digit photography over the last 50 years or so and the implications of this for the medium. It is a popular belief that digital photography cannot be trusted because the viewer never knows how much the photo they are looking at has been manipulated by editing programs. In the 1990s, photography was commonly used to "prove" science. Now in the digital age, photography possesses more of a sceptism than during this time. The skill of the photographer to point and shoot perfectly has been replaced by the skill to perfectly fix what one could not perfectly capture.
I wonder, though, if this belief is really true, and thus if this new-found sceptism is truly deserved. I was struck by this quote from Manovich: "Digital technology does not subvert "normal" photography because "normal" photography never existed". Before digital photography or photoshop ever existed, photographers could manipulate their photos in the dark room. They "fixed" just as much back then the old fashioned way as they do now...only difference is, there are more oportunities now. There are more programs with more editing options designed to make their edits look nonexistent. This begs the question, could scientific photography from the 1990's really be trusted any more than the photography shot today? Does having more or less options make one's choices in editing any less deceitful? And can this even really be called deceitful? Does the editing verses capturing skill of a photographer have any baring on the final product as long as the overall image is effective?
No comments:
Post a Comment