Sunday, March 16, 2014

Reading Response # 5

         In Chapter 5, Spectacles and Illusions: Photography and commodity Culture, John Tagg discusses how photographic portraiture has been used to distinguish social class for a long time.  Back before photography, only the truly wealthy could afford to heir painters to depict their families in all of their glory.  In the nineteenth century, photography allowed the middle and even lower-middle class to take their family portraits, and the same glorified styles and poses were used to simulate presumed wealth that the middle and lower classes wished to perceive.  The art of deception has been tied to photography since its invention.  In current society around the world, art, and photography in particular, is used to manipulate viewers to some end.  In our commerce-obsessed world, that end is normally to tell the viewer how to look...and what to buy to make them look like that.
          Many products are represented through photography displaying friendship, romance, or adventure.  The viewers are manipulated into envisioning themselves in that same scenario and wanting whatever will get them there.  Often times, however, that scenario never existed in real life, being a Photoshop fantasy instead.  It is a wonderful marketing strategy, but it is doing horrors on the actual individuals within our society, particularly women.  Women are conditioned to expect themselves to look like the glossy, photoshopped images they continually see in magazines and on billboards, and on posters in the mall.  Even the mannequins that wear the clothes they want are flawless.  The scary part is that photography and its editing tools have gotten so good that the public doesn't realize they are being tricked into idolizing an impossibility.  No one will ever be as perfect as a picture.  But that doesn't stop everyone from trying, from beauty pageants to breast augmentations, women around the world grow up being deceived by photography and giving in to the commerce that idolization supports.  But what happens when women become so self-criticizing that they lose any idea of their own identity and intrinsic worth?  Our society is currently questioning Hilary Clinton's ability to be an effective president in 2016 based on her "aging appearance" when both Ronald Regan and John McCain were older than she will be when they both ran for president.  80% of women in the United States go through some form of plastic surgery in their lifetime to avoid accusations like this!  Photography is a powerful medium.  It has the ability to influence its viewer possibly more than any other medium based solely on its prevalence in society.  I would like to know when morality will start to be considered in advertizing with the use of images.  Will it ever become illegal to manipulate a photograph for commercial purposes under the pretenses of false advertizing?  If so, where does one draw the line?  Is highlighting an underexposed part of an image to reveal what is actually there ok? If so, is darkening part of an image to conceal distracting, and or unwanted parts ok too?  
          

No comments:

Post a Comment